Home > Work Safety Law > Workplace Safety: Fines and Court Cases

Workplace Safety: Fines and Court Cases

By: Norman Thomson - Updated: 27 Dec 2016 | comments*Discuss
Health Safety Fines Court Cases Injury

Every year, hundreds of health and safety cases are taken to court by health and safety inspectors from the local authority and from the Health and Safety Executive (HSE). Reviewing these cases gives a good indication of how failures occur and how the enforcing authorities respond to such failure.

Here is a selection of recent cases:

Fall From a Ladder

An employee fell from a ladder while dismantling storage racking in an office. The ladder wasn’t secured properly and the employee had not been provided with proper training in the use of the ladder. The company was fined £20000.

Unsupervised Child

An employee brought a child into the factory where he worked. The child was allowed to move freely and unsupervised around the factory premises, which contained many different hazards and risks, including dangerous machinery. Local inspectors were called to the factory on another matter and found that the child was present. Inspectors claimed that the child was not only at risk of serious injury, but that he was also a distraction to employees. The company was fined £10000.

Meat Processing Plant

An employee got his hand trapped between two moving conveyor belts on a meat processing plant. Inspectors carried out an investigation and found that the injured employee had not been given any training in the use of the conveyor system. In addition, the company failed to provide proper guarding equipment around the conveyor belts and had failed to provide proper emergency stop buttons near to the belts. A massive fine of £95000 was imposed by the courts.

Trainee Falls to His Death

A 17 year old trainee was killed when he fell 18 metres into a sewage tank. The man was involved in constructing a scaffold inside the tank. The scaffold company had failed to provide proper work instructions on how to carry out this task. In addition, they had failed to provide training for the employee and had failed to provide adequate supervision. The company was fined £50000.

Another Fall

Falls are one of the most common types of accident at work. A worker was fitting metal gratings on a gantry, which was 35 metres above ground level. He lost his balance and fell to his death. The company was fined £45000 for failing to provide appropriate personal protective equipment and for failing to provide a safe system of work.

Radioactive Material

A radioactive source was removed from a radiotherapy machine in a hospital. The source was transported from the hospital for disposal by a licensed road transport company. However, when the source arrived at its destination, it was found to be emitting a high level beam of radiation through the bottom of the transportation container. It was found that a shield plug, which should have been fitted when the unit was removed from the radiotherapy machine, was missing, thereby allowing radiation to be emitted from the source. The judge said, ‘I find myself driven to the conclusion that the company must face a substantial penalty’. However, the company put forward a guilty plea and were awarded a discount of one third from their fine. The fine was £250000.

Even Emergency Services Are Not Exempt

A fire fighter was seriously injured when he slipped into a portable grain dryer on a farm. A fire had started inside the grain dryer and the fire fighter was sent inside to help clear the wet grain, which was clogging up the internal auger. However, he lost his footing and slid down into the auger, which was turning at the time. His foot was completely destroyed, and was later amputated at the ankle. The fire brigade was found to be negligent because they had failed to carry out proper risk assessment of this type of incident and had therefore failed to provide suitable procedures and safe systems of work. They were fined £2000.

All of the above incidents could have been prevented. Loss of life, personal injury, pain and long term disability occur because people fail to look at the hazards associated with their work. These cases highlight the need for employers to carry out risk assessments, to put proper procedures in place and to train their employees in the procedures, hazards and risks that exist. With a little thought and effort, pain and suffering as a result of accidents at work can be greatly reduced.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Is it too late for me to make a claim against a workplace where I fell down a flight of stairs and chipped the bone in my knee,back in 2008? My knee is ruined for life but I never did anything about it then!
Loulou - 27-Dec-16 @ 10:56 PM
Can anyone please advise me on what the H&S stance is on a pregnant worker driving MHE (VNA truck), many thanks
Lisa - 13-Jun-16 @ 12:04 PM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Chris
    Re: Ventilation in the Workplace
    I was a chef at a hotel, where the extractor fan broke down, bear in mind all my equipment cooker, fryer, and grill are gas, we…
    23 June 2019
  • Ruth
    Re: Dealing with Employee Theft
    I have been suspended from work as I have been accused of stealing umbrella from the lost property box can you advise please
    22 June 2019
  • Rhian
    Re: Dealing with Employee Theft
    I have been accused of theft and resigned from my position due to other staff being made aware and health issues. I have not…
    18 June 2019
  • Murrayben
    Re: Kitchen Workplace Safety
    Hello I work in a supermarket cafe and recently it’s just came to my attention that I haven’t had the full training to cook(even though…
    15 June 2019
  • monty
    Re: Do You Have the Correct Fire Extinguishers?
    In Scotland, if fire extinguishers are in place in a workplace, is it a legal requirement for staff to have…
    12 June 2019
  • Sinkie
    Re: Kitchen Workplace Safety
    Please can anyone advise if there is a regulation as to the minimum height a sink should be in a commercial catering business (Cafe).…
    11 June 2019
  • Nanjoes
    Re: Dealing with Employee Theft
    A friend of mine has been suspended from work under investigation she was a really good hard dedicated worker never stepped out of…
    11 June 2019
  • essie
    Re: Expectant Mothers in the Workplace
    a colleague of mine is 26 weeks pregnant. She has a desk job in an office. we have all been recently told that we can…
    7 June 2019
  • Andy
    Re: Ventilation in the Workplace
    Hello I work in a box factory. And I work on flyer machines. Witch they have to heat the glue. Witch raises the temperature. And…
    5 June 2019
  • JessA
    Re: Expectant Mothers in the Workplace
    Hi, I've been working for the same cleaning company for a little over 1 year which my job is cleaning schools. I'm…
    4 June 2019